Why do your bluffs never seem to work?
This is something a lot of my clients bring up during lessons.
They tell me that every single time they try to run a bluff, somebody calls them.
It doesn’t matter what they’re representing.
It doesn’t matter how carefully they think they’ve constructed the hand.
Somebody always seems to look them up.
Well, there’s usually a reason for that.
Actually, there are several reasons.
Today, I’m going to explain why I see most bluffs fail and give you some adjustments you can make to start bluffing more effectively.
Let’s get right into it.
1. You’re bluffing too much on the river
This is probably the biggest piece of advice I could give you.
Stop bluffing so much on the river.
Now, obviously, there are situations where river bluffs are profitable.
I’m not telling you to never bluff the river.
But against most low-stakes opponents, you need to cherry-pick those situations extremely carefully.
Why?
Because the average recreational player gets to the river, looks at the pot, and thinks, “Oh wow, I’ve already invested so much money. I really want to see what this guy has.”
Then they call.
Sometimes they’ll sit there for three minutes before making that call.
They’ll stare at the board.
They’ll count their chips.
They’ll look miserable.
They’ll act like they’re making the most difficult decision of their entire life.
But a lot of the time, they’re not actually thinking about anything.
They already decided they wanted to call.
You want to know how you can tell?
Listen to their explanations afterward.
The rationalizations are often utter nonsense.
They’ll tell you they put you on some incredibly specific hand that doesn’t even make sense given the action.
Or they’ll say they just had a feeling.
Or they’ll tell everybody they couldn’t fold because there was too much money in the pot.
The reality is that they didn’t feel like folding.
They’re there to gamble.
You’re not necessarily playing against someone who’s carefully analyzing your range.
You’re playing against a gambler who wants to see your cards.
And that’s a huge distinction.
Don’t run some incredibly subtle bluff against a typical punter and expect them to appreciate how sophisticated your line is.
You’re playing Beethoven to a cow.
They don’t care.
They have a pair.
They want to see what you have.
And they’re going to call.
2. You’re bluffing when the flush draw misses
This is another enormous mistake.
A lot of players see their opponent call on a board with a flush draw and make a reasonable observation.
They think, “Well, if this guy had a set or two pair, he probably would have raised.”
And that’s often true.
Many recreational players raise their strongest hands on coordinated boards because they want value and don’t want somebody completing a flush against them.
So when their opponent just calls, they correctly conclude that the range contains a lot of mediocre pairs and draws.
So far, so good.
But then the river comes.
The flush draw misses.
And they decide to bluff.
That’s where everything falls apart.
Why?
Because the most common excuse low-stakes players give for making a ridiculously large call is, “I put you on a missed draw.”
They can see the missed flush draw.
They know that somebody could have been chasing it.
And that’s all the justification they need to call with a mediocre pair.
It doesn’t matter that your betting line might represent a huge hand.
It doesn’t matter that your opponent has a weak bluff-catcher.
They’re thinking, “The flush missed. I think he’s bluffing.”
And they put the money in.
This is one of the reasons I tell people to be extremely careful about bluffing missed flush draws.
You’re choosing a situation where your opponent already has a convenient excuse to call.
If anything, you should be value betting much more thinly against these players.
When the flush draw misses and you have a decent hand, consider making a bigger value bet.
You might be surprised by how lightly they call.
Stop trying to bluff people who are practically begging for an excuse to look you up.
3. You’re not betting more than the size of the pot
Most of your opponents don’t actually think about your range.
They look at their hand.
They look at the board.
Then they look at your bet size.
It’s almost like they’re playing an arcade game.
They’re not sitting there thinking about how your range interacts with theirs.
They’re asking themselves whether they like their hand enough to call the amount you’ve bet.
And this creates a tremendous opportunity.
When you make a really large bet, they become uncomfortable.
They look at their mediocre hand and think, “Wow, that’s a lot of money.”
They start worrying that they’ll look like an idiot if they call such a huge bet and lose.
But when you make a smaller bet, the emotional equation changes.
Now they think, “Well, that’s not too expensive.”
Then they worry they’ll look stupid if they fold and you turn out to be bluffing.
Here’s where a lot of people make mistakes.
What you consider a big bet is not necessarily what a recreational gambler considers a big bet.
You and I might look at a bet of 75% of the pot and consider that a reasonably large wager.
But your opponent has seen that bet size a million times.
They’re comfortable with it.
They think, “I’ve seen people bluff with this sizing plenty of times. I’m going to feel really stupid if I fold.”
So they call.
That’s why I want you to start thinking about overbetting more often when you’re trying to get mediocre hands to fold.
Against the right opponent, a bet larger than the pot creates a completely different emotional reaction.
Suddenly, they’re not just wondering whether you’re bluffing.
They’re wondering whether they really want to risk that much money with such a mediocre hand.
And that’s the question you want them asking themselves.
4. You’re not overbetting the turn enough
There’s one bluff that absolutely prints money against many mediocre opponents.
Overbetting the turn.
Let’s go through an example.
Somebody calls your preflop raise.
The flop comes with a flush draw.
You continuation bet.
Your opponent calls.
Now think about their range.
A lot of these players would have three-bet their strongest overpairs preflop.
They also would have check-raised their sets or two pairs on the flop because they don’t want to let you complete a flush.
So when they just call, what do they often have?
Mediocre pairs.
Some draws.
Maybe a few weak top pairs.
Now let’s say the turn brings an overcard that doesn’t complete the flush draw.
This is a fantastic card to consider attacking.
Why?
Because it doesn’t help most of their draws.
And it makes a lot of their flopped pairs look much worse.
Now imagine you bet 75% of the pot.
Against a thinking player, that can look like a reasonably strong value bet.
But remember who you’re playing against.
This is somebody who isn’t necessarily thinking about your range.
They’re thinking, “This guy thinks he’s better than me.”
They look at their pair.
They look at your bet.
And they decide they don’t want to fold.
If they call and you actually have a big hand, they can spend the rest of the evening complaining about how unlucky they are.
But if they fold and you were bluffing?
They’ll feel like an idiot.
So they call.
You need to change the equation.
What if you bet two times the size of the pot instead?
Now, mathematically speaking, a pure bluff of two times the pot only needs to work two-thirds of the time to break even.
That’s about 66.7%.
That means your opponent needs to continue with roughly one-third of their range to stop you from automatically profiting with any two cards, assuming you have no equity when called.
Now think about how difficult that is for a typical recreational opponent.
They have a mediocre pair.
The turn brought an overcard.
The flush draw didn’t complete.
And you’re suddenly betting twice the size of the pot.
That is a completely different decision.
If they call that enormous bet with second pair and you turn over a set, they’re going to feel like the dumbest person who ever walked the Earth.
Everybody at the table just watched them put a huge amount of money into the pot with a mediocre hand.
They don’t want that.
So they fold.
You’ve given them a permission slip to fold.
And when they do fold, don’t ruin it.
You can say, “Nice fold.”
Or you can simply say nothing.
Never show your bluff.
Never rub it in their face.
You want them to keep thinking that your enormous bets represent enormous hands.
That’s how you get this bluff to keep working.
5. You’re thinking about your range when your opponent doesn’t care about your range
This is another mistake I see all the time.
A player will explain a bluff to me by talking about their range.
They’ll say, “Well, I have the range advantage here.”
Or, “This turn card is much better for my range.”
Or, “I can represent all the strongest hands.”
And sometimes they’re absolutely right.
But here’s the problem.
Their opponent doesn’t care.
Most recreational players aren’t thinking about what you’re representing.
They’re thinking about their own hand and what the latest card did to it.
That’s it.
Let’s say your opponent has a weak pair.
The turn comes, and it’s an undercard.
What does your opponent think?
They think, “Great! That probably didn’t help him.”
So they call.
Now let’s say the turn pairs the board.
Again, a lot of recreational players aren’t doing some complicated analysis of how the paired card changes your range.
They just think, “Well, that probably didn’t help him either.”
And they call.
But what happens when the turn brings an overcard?
Now they’re worried.
Their pair doesn’t look so good anymore.
What happens when the turn completes an obvious draw?
Again, they’re worried.
They can see that something changed.
That creates tension.
And that tension is exactly what you want when you’re bluffing.
You need to think about which cards actually frighten your specific opponent.
Not just which cards are theoretically good for your range.
There’s a huge difference.
If you’re playing against somebody who understands ranges, you can use those sophisticated concepts to construct your bluffs.
But if you’re playing against somebody who only looks at their own two cards, you need to bluff in situations where those cards suddenly look much less attractive.
Stop trying to convince people of something they’re not even thinking about.
6. You’re missing the easiest bluff against recreational players
I can’t believe I’m giving this one away.
But if you play low-stakes cash games around the country, this is one of the most powerful bluffs you can look for.
There are a lot of recreational players who do the exact same thing every time they make a straight or a flush.
They lead out large.
Every single time.
They don’t want to risk you checking behind.
They don’t want to miss value.
They finally made their big hand, and they’re excited to get paid.
So they bet big.
Now think about what that means.
What happens when the flush draw completes, and that same player checks to you?
What happens when they lead out for just 25% of the pot instead of making their usual huge bet?
They’re often telling you something incredibly valuable.
They don’t like the completed draw.
They might have a mediocre pair.
They might have two pair.
They might have a set that suddenly looks much worse.
But against the players who consistently bet big when they make their draws, that small bet or check can be a huge sign of weakness.
And that’s when you should consider bluffing.
Against certain opponents with a reliable sizing tell, I’ve found that this bluff works an astonishing percentage of the time.
They practically announce that they don’t have the flush or straight.
And then you put serious pressure on them.
They look at their hand, realize they don’t have the completed draw, and fold.
That’s it.
You don’t need some incredibly complicated solver line.
You just need to notice how your opponent behaves when they make a big hand.
Then pay attention when they suddenly behave differently.
Now, you should absolutely establish that this is a genuine tendency before attacking it repeatedly.
Some players are perfectly capable of checking strong hands.
Others will lead small as a trap.
But when you identify someone who reliably gives away their hand strength, you need to take advantage of that weakness.
And here’s one more thing.
Don’t reveal what you’re doing.
If somebody catches you bluffing in one of these spots, don’t start explaining the read to the entire table.
I’ve even had situations where I took my hand, looked at it again, and acted surprised, saying something like, “Oh my God, I thought I had something else. Good call.” Then, I mucked, so no one could see what I had.
Why?
Because I don’t want them knowing that I’ve identified this particular weakness.
I want them to keep doing it.
I want them to keep making those huge bets when they make a flush.
I want them to keep checking or betting tiny when they’re scared of a completed draw.
And I want to keep taking advantage of it.
A lot of people spend years searching for elaborate bluffs when some of the most profitable ones are sitting right in front of them.
You just need to pay attention.
That’s my time for today.
I hope these six tips help you the next time you’re thinking about running a bluff.
Remember, successful bluffing isn’t about making the fanciest play.
It’s about choosing opponents who can actually fold, identifying situations where their ranges are weak, and using bet sizes that put meaningful pressure on them.
If you want to go much deeper into this subject, be sure to check out my master class, Master Bluffing in One Class.
This is over five hours of training designed to show you how to bluff effectively and profitably in both cash games and tournaments.
And right now, it’s 50% off.
Instead of paying $99.99, you can get the entire training package for just $49.
However, there are only 20 copies available at that price.
Once those 20 discounted copies are gone, the website will tell you that the coupon code has expired.
So don’t delay.
If you’re tired of having your bluffs called and want to learn which bluffs actually work against the opponents in your games, this is a great place to start.
Wishing you the best of luck on the felt.
